Current:Home > MyDepartment of Agriculture Conservation Programs Are Giving Millions to Farms That Worsen Climate Change -DataFinance
Department of Agriculture Conservation Programs Are Giving Millions to Farms That Worsen Climate Change
View
Date:2025-04-16 03:52:48
The Department of Agriculture gives tens of millions of dollars every year to farmers and ranchers to support conservation efforts on their farms, but much of the funding ends up at big, industrial-scale operations that critics say worsen agricultural pollution and emit climate-warming greenhouse gases, a new report has found.
The report, released last week by the Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy, concluded that one of the agency’s biggest and most popular conservation programs, the Environmental Quality Incentives Program (EQIP), gave out its costliest grants in 2022 to seven large dairy farms in California, the country’s biggest dairy-producing state.
These grants, nearly $300,000 each, were for construction of anaerobic digesters, which capture methane gas from lagoons where manure is collected. The methane is then converted into “biogas” that gets routed into pipelines to heat homes and buildings.
In all, more than $100 million in grants were awarded across the country for such digesters that capture methane from manure and other infrastructure at large concentrated animal feeding operations for dairy cows and cattle, or CAFOs.
The USDA classifies digesters as conservation measures because they capture and divert methane, an especially potent greenhouse gas, from entering the atmosphere. But, critics say, funneling millions of dollars to construct digesters and other waste equipment incentivizes the expansion of massive dairy and cattle operations—and only intensifies the country’s biggest source of agricultural methane: cow burps.
The IATP analysis looked at practices that the USDA identifies as having conservation benefits and calculated which of them were getting the most money.
“We found that eight out of the top 10 go to support industrial scale farms,” said Michael Happ, an IATP researcher who authored the report. “But when you look at the most effective practices, they’re not going to the types of farms that are making the climate crisis worse.”
The EQIP program was launched in the early 1990s to help farmers pay for conservation measures on their farms, such as planting grasses to prevent erosion or creating windbreaks. It has become very popular with farmers; the USDA turns thousands of potential grantees away each year.
In the 2002 Farm Bill, the sprawling legislation covering farm and nutrition policy that’s re-negotiated every five years, lawmakers allowed CAFOs to be recipients of EQIP dollars.
“It was part of a compromise between those who wanted to increase conservation spending and those from livestock-heavy states,” Happ explained. “Since then, funding going to large CAFOs has gone through the roof.”
As of March 2020, 255 digesters were operating on American livestock farms. At least 59 more have come online since then, according to the Environmental Protection Agency.
In addition to digesters, the EQIP program also funds other costly CAFO-related infrastructure, such as waste treatment lagoons and storage facilities. The Biden administration has said that methane digesters would be a key component of its efforts to reduce emissions from agriculture, placing them on its list of “climate smart” practices. The Inflation Reduction Act, which directs nearly $19 billion to the USDA, specifies that nearly $8.5 billion of that will go to the EQIP program.
“When we look at the list of climate-smart practices there are a lot of things that we support,” Happ said. “Digesters are listed as a climate smart practice and that’s something we strongly disagree with.”
Late last year, the Environmental Working Group, which has extensively tracked conservation funding and agricultural subsidies, found that the USDA had given more than $7 billion to farmers through its major conservation programs, including EQIP, from 2017 to 2020, yet only a small percentage of the funding went to practices that had any climate benefits, the group found.
“We know that EQIP funding is not going to the right practices,” said Anne Schechinger, a director with the group and author of the study. That analysis found that of the 10 practices that received the most funding—roughly half of the overall funding—only one had climate benefits, while the other 200 practices the agency supported got the other half of the funding.
“That means there are tons of great conservation practices that are getting almost no money,” Schechinger said. “And yet we’re spending millions of dollars on things that most people would not consider to be conservation.”
In response to a request for answers and an interview, the USDA sent an emailed statement, saying that the agency last year announced $325 million for a program called the Partnerships for Climate-Smart Commodities, which focuses on “innovative projects that emphasize enrolling small and underserved producers.” This brings that agency’s total investment for climate-smart agriculture to more than $3 billion, the agency said.
“In addition, the Inflation Reduction Act provided $19.5 billion for climate-smart agriculture, enabling USDA to increase access to its oversubscribed conservation programs. These additional investments are estimated to help hundreds of thousands of farmers and ranchers apply conservation to millions of acres of land,” the agency said, noting that many of these conservation practices would have direct climate benefits.
veryGood! (39)
Related
- Highlights from Trump’s interview with Time magazine
- Matthew Stafford reports to training camp after Rams, QB modify contract
- New owner nears purchase of Red Lobster after chain announced bankruptcy and closures
- Some Republicans are threatening legal challenges to keep Biden on the ballot. But will they work?
- Nearly half of US teens are online ‘constantly,’ Pew report finds
- Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle resigns after Trump shooting security lapses
- Blake Lively Shares Proof Ryan Reynolds Is Most Romantic Person on the Planet
- FTC launches probe into whether surveillance pricing can boost costs for consumers
- Nearly half of US teens are online ‘constantly,’ Pew report finds
- Bachelor Nation's Ashley Iaconetti Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 2 With Jared Haibon
Ranking
- Tree trimmer dead after getting caught in wood chipper at Florida town hall
- Blake Lively Shares Proof Ryan Reynolds Is Most Romantic Person on the Planet
- John Mulaney's Ex Anna Marie Tendler Details Her 2-Week Stay at Psychiatric Hospital
- Terrell Davis' lawyer releases video of United plane handcuffing incident, announces plans to sue airline
- NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
- Maine will decide on public benefit of Juniper Ridge landfill by August
- NFL Star Joe Burrow Shocks Eminem Fans With Slim Shady-Inspired Transformation
- The Secret Service budget has swelled to more than $3 billion. Here's where the money goes.
Recommendation
Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
Mattel introduces its first blind Barbie, new Barbie with Down syndrome
BETA GLOBAL FINANCE: The Radiant Path of the Cryptocurrency Market
Massachusetts issues tighter restrictions on access to homeless shelter system
As Trump Enters Office, a Ripe Oil and Gas Target Appears: An Alabama National Forest
Judge asked to block slave descendants’ effort to force a vote on zoning of their Georgia community
Bangladesh protests death toll nears 180, with more than 2,500 people arrested after days of unrest
Trump expected to turn his full focus on Harris at first rally since Biden’s exit from 2024 race